Yes, car insurance can cover a black ice accident in North Dakota, but the type of coverage matters. If you slide into another vehicle, hit a guardrail, or roll into a ditch, collision coverage generally pays for damage to your car. No-fault (PIP) covers qualifying medical expenses and lost income, up to $30,000 per person, regardless of who caused the crash. If another driver slid into you and was at fault, you may be able to recover the cost of your car repairs through their liability insurance. A serious injury, including one involving more than $2,500 in qualifying medical expenses, may also allow you to seek compensation for pain and suffering.
| Question | Answer | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Does comprehensive cover a black ice slide? | No. Collision covers hitting a vehicle or object or overturning; comprehensive covers damage “other than collision” | ND Insurance Department, auto page |
| Who pays my medical bills? | No-fault, up to $30,000 per person, from the insurer of the vehicle you were in | N.D.C.C. §§ 26.1-41-01(2), 26.1-41-13(2) |
| Is the driver who slid at fault? | Usually. Drivers must keep a speed that is reasonable for “weather, or highway conditions” | § 39-09-01(1) |
| When can I sue for pain and suffering? | Serious injury: death, dismemberment, serious and permanent disfigurement, disability beyond 60 days, or medical expenses over $2,500 | §§ 26.1-41-01(21), 26.1-41-08 |
| What if I was partly at fault? | Your damages drop by your share; you recover nothing if your fault is as great as everyone else’s combined | § 32-03.2-02 |
| Do I have to report it? | Yes, immediately, if anyone is hurt or damage appears to be $4,000 or more | § 39-08-09(1) |
Which insurance pays after a black ice crash in North Dakota?
A black ice crash can involve four different types of coverage. Here’s what each one pays for:
| Coverage | What it pays for | Required? |
|---|---|---|
| No-fault (PIP) | Your medical bills, lost wages, and other economic loss, regardless of fault, up to $30,000 | Yes |
| Liability | Injuries and property damage you cause to others ($25,000 / $50,000 / $25,000 minimum) | Yes |
| Collision | Damage to your car from hitting a vehicle or object, or overturning, regardless of fault | No |
| Comprehensive | Damage to your car from something other than a collision | No |
No-fault coverage pays for injuries and related losses, not car repairs. As the North Dakota Insurance Department explains: “neither no-fault nor uninsured motorist coverage provides coverage for physical damage to your vehicle.”
Does comprehensive insurance cover black ice?
No. A black ice crash is generally a collision claim when your car hits something or overturns. Here’s how the North Dakota Insurance Department distinguishes the two coverages:
- Collision covers physical damage “caused by colliding with some other vehicle or object or by overturning the vehicle.” It “pays regardless of who causes the accident.”
- Comprehensive covers physical damage “caused by items other than collision such as theft, fire, vandalism, hail, falling objects, or hitting an animal.”
Sliding on ice into a car, a pole, a fence, or a snowbank is a collision. So is rolling over in the ditch. Comprehensive comes into play on icy days only when the damage isn’t a collision, such as ice or a branch falling on your car, or hitting a deer.
Collision coverage isn’t required. Check your policy’s declarations page to see whether you have it and what deductible applies. Without collision coverage, you may have to pay for repairs yourself after a single-car slide.
What if you slid on black ice and hit nothing but a snowbank or ditch?
If you’re injured, no-fault coverage is generally the first place to turn. The insurer of the vehicle you occupied pays first (N.D.C.C. § 26.1-41-13(2)), and anyone else riding in your car also gets no-fault benefits from your vehicle’s insurer (§ 26.1-41-06(2)). Your car goes through collision, minus the deductible.
Some one-car crashes also have to be reported. A driver must immediately notify police, the sheriff, or the Highway Patrol when a crash causes injury or death, or apparent property damage of $4,000 or more (N.D.C.C. § 39-08-09). The fine for not reporting is $50. A crash with a wild animal that damages only your own vehicle is exempt from that notice rule.
What if another driver slid on black ice and hit you?
Your injuries still go through no-fault first, from the insurer of the vehicle you were in, even though the other driver caused the crash. North Dakota no-fault pays “without regard to fault” (§ 26.1-41-06).
For damage to your car, you can make a claim against the other driver’s property damage liability coverage, which must carry at least $25,000 in limits. You can also use your own collision coverage and have your insurer seek reimbursement from the other driver.
For pain and suffering, you need a “serious injury” under N.D.C.C. § 26.1-41-01(21): death, dismemberment, serious and permanent disfigurement, disability beyond 60 days, or medical expenses over $2,500. If you got care free or at a discount, its usual value counts toward the $2,500.
Economic loss beyond no-fault is different. The at-fault driver is protected from economic loss only up to the no-fault benefits paid or payable (§ 26.1-41-08(1)(b)). No-fault caps work loss at $150 a week and total benefits at $30,000, so lost wages and medical bills above those limits can be claimed from the other driver without meeting the serious-injury threshold.
For how these claims move, see our page on car accident claims in North Dakota.
Who is at fault for a black ice accident in North Dakota?
Usually the driver who slid. The basic speed rule says no one may drive “at a speed greater than is reasonable and prudent under the conditions.” Drivers must use a safe speed “when special hazards exist with respect to pedestrians, other traffic, weather, or highway conditions” (N.D.C.C. § 39-09-01(1)). Breaking that rule is careless driving, with a $100 fee. Ice is a normal part of a North Dakota winter. It doesn’t excuse driving too fast or following too closely.
North Dakota does recognize a sudden emergency doctrine, but the Supreme Court keeps it narrow. In Tidd v. Kroshus, 2015 ND 248, the court explained that the doctrine covers only emergencies “not caused by that person’s own negligence,” and that “every unexpected occurrence does not constitute a sudden emergency.” The same opinion noted two earlier cases where the court let juries consider the doctrine because a driver unexpectedly hit a slippery spot on the road. Whether a true emergency existed is usually a question for the jury.
To determine fault, insurers and attorneys look at speed, following distance, tire condition, road reports, photographs, and the crash report. Our post on proving fault in severe weather crashes goes deeper.
What if both drivers were partly at fault on the ice?
North Dakota uses modified comparative fault (N.D.C.C. § 32-03.2-02). Your compensation is reduced by your percentage of fault. If your fault is as great as the combined fault of everyone else, you recover nothing. Each at-fault party pays only its own share.
A second rule protects small property-damage claims. Under § 32-03.2-02.1, your property damage is not reduced for your share of fault when:
- Two drivers were at fault.
- Your direct property damage is $5,000 or less, and your indirect damage, such as a rental, is $1,000 or less.
- The other driver was more than 50 percent at fault.
This rule covers property only, not injury damages.
For example, suppose you’re 30 percent at fault and the other driver is 70 percent at fault. Your repair bill is $4,200 and your rental is $600. Under the normal rule, you’d recover 70 percent of $4,800, or $3,360. Under § 32-03.2-02.1, you recover the full $4,800.
What should you do after a black ice crash?
The Insurance Department’s checklist:
- Call for medical help if needed.
- Call the police and remain at the scene.
- Get the name, address, driver’s license number, and insurance company of everyone involved.
- Get the names and addresses of any witnesses.
- Write down the details, and notify your agent or company.
On ice, also photograph the road surface before it’s sanded or melts. Give the officer your insurance carrier and policy number, as § 39-08-09 requires. If another driver was at fault, contact their insurer to put them on notice.
Don’t overlook the filing deadlines. If no no-fault benefits have been paid, a lawsuit for them generally must be filed within two years after you know of the loss and that the crash caused it, and no later than four years after the crash. If some were paid, you have four years from the last payment (§ 26.1-41-19). A lawsuit against the at-fault driver for injuries generally has a six-year deadline (N.D.C.C. § 28-01-16). Our guide to how a car accident injury claim moves forward walks through the steps.
Frequently asked questions
Does car insurance cover black ice?
Yes. Collision covers your car when you slide into something, no-fault covers your medical bills and lost wages up to $30,000, and liability covers damage you cause to others.
Does comprehensive insurance cover black ice?
No. North Dakota’s Insurance Department defines comprehensive as damage from causes “other than collision,” such as hail or falling objects. A slide into a vehicle or object, or a rollover, is collision.
Is black ice an at-fault accident?
Usually. North Dakota requires drivers to slow for weather and road conditions, so the driver who slid is often found at fault unless the ice was a true emergency they did not help create.
Will no-fault pay if I caused the black ice crash?
Yes. Basic no-fault benefits are paid without regard to fault under § 26.1-41-06.
Can I sue the driver who slid into me?
Yes, for economic loss beyond no-fault, and for pain and suffering if your injury is serious, such as more than $2,500 in medical expenses or disability beyond 60 days.
What to do next
Start by checking your policy for collision coverage and no-fault benefits. Keep your medical bills and repair estimates, and report the crash if anyone was injured or the apparent damage is $4,000 or more. For next time, review our winter driving tips for North Dakota roads. If another driver’s slide left you hurt, a North Dakota personal injury lawyer can tell you whether your injury crosses the serious-injury line and what the claim can include.